But her close friend has given details on what The video was posted by Disha in … Disha is seen partying in the video in a lighthearted jovial mood. Notably, Disha died on June 8 by jumping from the 14th floor. It is being reported that a call was made from Disha Salian's phone to number 100, which belongs to the Mumbai Police Control Room, right before her death. This party took place just before Disha’s death. An eyewitness tells media that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party held on the eve of her death: Here are the details Amongst the 4 people who allegedly sexually assaulted Disha, one was allegedly a close friend of hers and another was a minister's security guard, claimed the eyewitness. Disha Salian Call Police before party with aditya thackeray and sooraj pancholi , The Lokmanch Another disturbing fact that has emerged is that Disha Salian’s post-mortem was conducted two days after her death. Tags: Bihar Police Bihar police Disha Salian Disha Salian Bihar police Disha Salian Sushant Singh Rajput Entertainment News Bollywood NewsTrending News Rashami Desai after speaking about late friend Disha Salian's death: Invasion of my privacy in the name of news isn't cool Karanvir Bohra and Shruti Seth … A video of Disha Salian has surfaced in which she was seen partying with her friends before she died. Check it out The death mystery of Sushant Singh … The death mystery of Sushant Singh has created suspense everywhere. […] A division bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice G.S. Maharashtra SSC, HSC supplementary exam result 2020 declared at mahresult.n... SBI PO Admit Card 2020 released at sbi.co.in for over 2000 posts; direct li... PM Modi to address centenary celebrations of Visva-Bharati University today. Last month, actor Arbaz Khan had filed a complaint against Vibhor Anand for naming him in the Disha Salian case. Smita went on to reveal that Sushant must have known something about Disha Salian's death which was termed 'Suicide' just after two days by Mumbai Police. The last moments of Disha Salian were captured by her in a video, just few hours before she allegedly committed suicide. DNA Explainer: Why do we greet "Merry Christmas” and not “Happy Christ... Do face masks disrupt facial perception? Late celebrity manager Disha Salian's friend, Amit Tuli, has said she did not have any suicidal tendencies and was doing fine. In the latest in Republic's investigation into the death case of Disha Salian, who was Sushant Singh Rajput's manager, a third friend of Disha who was allegedly present in the party has been tracked down. It is said that the video was allegedly taken hours before her death, and captures some of her last moments. Following the incident, Disha called up Sushant Singh Rajput, her former employer, to seek help. A video of Disha Salian has surfaced in which she was seen partying with her friends before she died. Sushant, 34, was found dead at his Bandra residence on June 14, 2020. A … As per reports, she attended a party just before her death. The mystery surrounding Disha Salian's death refuses to die dowm with many speculations doing the drive across media portals. The flat agreement had recently been finalised by her fiancé Rohan Roy. News Flash- Before Committing Sucide Party Video Of Sushant Singh Rajput Ex Manger Disha Salian Video Goes Viral On Social Media #SushantDeathMystery #FollowMe For More Updates … Disha Salian’s LAST Video Partying With Friends Before Death Goes Viral, WATCH Disha Salian passed away on the night of 8th June. Disha Salian died on June 9. Watch - Disha Salian's Alleged Last Video Before Her Death From a Party Shows Her in Good Spirits- … In the video we can also see Disha's friends enjoying the party. And now, to add to the mystery further, an undated video of Disha Sailan is doing the rounds of the internet and is going viral. In the video, we can see Disha along with her fiancé Rohan Roy and a group of her very close friends at their Malad's new flat. Sushant Singh Rajput's former manager, Disha Salian, died on June 8 after falling off the 14th floor of a building in Mumbai. Investigation in the case is underway. Disha Salian passed away on the night of 8th June. There were reports in the beginning that the actor has committed suicide. Disha Salian called Sushant Singh Rajput hours before her death on June 8 - Reports. Mumbai Police, denying the reports, said that everything about the Disha Salian death case is on record. An undated video of Disha Salian, the former manager of late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, has found its way on the internet, and shows her in good spirits, enjoying a house party with friends. DNA Explainer: Cairn Energy wins arbitration award against India in tax dis... LPG cylinder prices may change every week from next year, Power ministry brings new rules to protect consumers. Netizens have been calling for an investigation of Disha Salian's death case. The ex-manager of Sushant Singh Rajput was seen happily partying with her close friends. She fell from the 14th floor of a building in Jankalyan Nagar, Malvani in Mumbai’s Malad West. Mumbai: Even as speculations are rife that Sushant Singh Rajput’s former manager Disha Salian was murdered, an eyewitness has stepped forward to claim that the celebrity manager was gang-raped before her demise on June 8. He was doing meditation. Social media is full of conspiracy theories and rumours about Disha Salian. While she had died on the night of 8-9 June, documents show that the post-mortem was done on 11 th June.. Soon after attending the party, she was found dead. According to the news channel’s report, Prashant said that an anonymous caller informed him about a high profile party held on June 8 in which someone misbehaved with Disha Salian. Disha Salian did not dial 100 before death: Police Dispelling rumours that the last call from celebrity manager Disha Salian's phone was to the police emergency service, the Mumbai Police on Friday said that her last phone call was to a friend. There were also rumours of Suraj Pancholi's link with Disha which may have caused for a confrontation between him and Sushant's friends at a different party. A video of … Sushant, aged 34, was found dead in his Bandra apartment under mysterious circumstances, just like his ex-manager. Dispelling rumours that the last call from celebrity manager Disha Salian's phone was to the police emergency service, the Mumbai Police on Friday said that her last phone call was to a friend. Observing that any citizen having any information regarding the alleged mysterious death of Disha Salian can approach the Mumbai Police, the Bombay High Court on … A close family friend of Sushant Singh Rajput has sensationally revealed that the actor's reported suicide could be linked to the death of his manager Disha Salian. Trump threatens to not sign $892 billion COVID-19 relief bill, wants bigger... Bhutan announces seven-day nationwide lockdown amid rising COVID-19 cases, Beware! Check it out. Disha Salian did not dial 100 before death: Police. Celebrity Manager Disha Salian's Family Issues Statement After Her Death The mystery death cases of Disha Sailan and Sushant Singh Rajput seem to be getting murkier day by day. So far, we have seen several theories that have been linking the death of Sushant Singh Rajput with that of his ex-manager Disha Sailan. According to reports, she had attended a party right before being found dead. Young celebrity manager Disha Salian had reportedly died by suicide by jumping off the 14th floor of her apartment in Malad, Mumbai on the night of … The ex-manager of Sushant Singh Rajput was seen happily partying with her close friends. Disha had reportedly jumped off a high-rise apartment on June 8, 2020. Speaking about the consecutive deaths of Sushant Singh Rajput and his ex-manager Disha Salian on 'The Debate with Arnab Goswami', Prashant claimed that he received an anonymous call from someone claiming to be Disha's friend and informed him about a party which allegedly took place on June 8 - the day when Disha committed suicide. After this, Disha Salian called Sushant. Now as per a report in News Nation, an eyewitness said that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party which she attended on the eve of … In Pic: Hrithik Roshan watches 'Wonder Woman 1984' with Sussanne... 'The holy trinity is complete': Karanvir Bohra expresses happines... Pakistan: ETPB “sides” with land grabbers who encroached houses of Sikhs, Pfizer to supply US with 100 million more COVID-19 shots by July. Disha, 28, allegedly jumped off a high-rise apartment in Mumbai on June 8. It is said that the video was allegedly taken hours before her death, and captures some of her last moments. Does this video deflate the claim of a politician being present at the party? Mumbai Police after 2 days of investigation closed the case by calling it a suicide. The mystery surrounding Disha Salian's death refuses to die dowm with many speculations doing the drive across media portals. The case of 28-year-old Disha's death has opened up once again after many people have claimed a link between her demise and actor Sushant Singh Rajput's death on June 14, 2020. Disha Salian, who managed Varun Sharma and Sushant Singh Rajput (for a short time) died on June 8, 2020. The CBI is still investigating the SSR case, while the Disha Salian case remains closed. Kulkarni observed that the petitioner, Delhi-based advocate Puneet … The Mumbai Police has urged people to share any evidence which they have related to a link between Disha and Sushant's demse. MUMBAI: The SSR and Disha cases, which seem to be related, are presently among the most sensational and talked about ones in the nation. Mumbai: An undated video of Disha Salian, the former manager of late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, has found its way on the internet, and shows her in good spirits, enjoying a house party with friends. The advocate allegedly levelled several such allegations against the people named. A BJP MLA from Andheri has written to Mumbai Police to investigate if Disha Salian had attended a party at Sushant Singh Rajput's house. Disha Salian called Sushant Singh Rajput hours before her death on June 8 - Reports Amidst the constantly surfacing facts about Sushant Singh Rajput’s death case Prashant Kumar, an activist who runs the campaign ‘Insaaf SSR’ demanding justice for the late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, made a sensational revelation on Monday. It was also reported that case files of Disha Salian are missing or have been deleted. Home » Entertainment » Bollywood » disha salian last party video before death only with close friends hap Disha Salian केस में बड़ा खुलासा: मौत के कुछ देर पहले का Video आया सामने, पार्टी में सिर्फ मंगेतर और क्लोज फ्रेंड Disha Salian's Happy Video Enjoying With Friends Before She Was Found Dead Goes Viral. New developments keep cropping up which results in fresh twists and turns in the already complicated case. Is it her last video before death? However, she too has refused to speak up with someone in her family insisting that 'she is busy' and 'cannot talk'. Recently, the death news of young girl Disha Salian shocked everyone. Here is a video of Disha salian doing party before her suicide. Reportedly, there was a party at Disha Salian's house before her death which was attended by powerful politicians. It is said that the video was allegedly taken hours before her death, and captures some of her last moments. The reports have not come yet. Baby Penguin was present in the Party. Salian was in a flat on the 14th floor at the time. Now the some friends of Disha have something else to say about this whole matter. As Disha Salian’s death is being investigated once again, a video, which is being claimed to be shot hours before her demise, is going viral on social media. Speaking exclusively to India Today, Disha's father, Satish Salian, revealed that it … She told the incident to Sushant before her murder that's why he was also murdered. Here is a video of Disha salian doing party before her suicide. It is known that a few days before the death of Sushant, the news of Disha Salian’s death had come out. An undated video of Disha Salian, the former manager of late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, has found its way on the internet, and shows her in good spirits, enjoying a house party with friends. A video of her enjoying the evening with her friends has also popped up online. COVID-19: Cricket Australia bans players from cutting hair during BBL 2020... South Africa vs Sri Lanka 1st Test: Lankan skipper Dimuth Karunaratne revea... Jay Shah's Secretary XI defeated President XI led by Sourav Ganguly at... R Ashwin's records speak for his own: Nathan Lyon on comparison with I... ICC T20I Rankings: Virat Kohli leaps to 7th spot, KL Rahul retains third po... UP Board Exams 2021: Last date for online submission of forms, fees extende... BIG: Class 10 and 12 Board Exams in June next year in this state; know more. Simi Garewal feels that Sushant Singh Rajput’s former manager Disha Salian’s death needs to be investigated, to reveal the ‘conspiracy’ behind his death. According to reports, she had attended a party right before being found She was partying with her friends at … or it is archival footage? A video of Disha Salian partying has been made public. But the bigger question is. Well, cops must investigate. The party was said to be at her friend's residence and soon after attending it, … According to recent claims, Disha had dialled the emergency number 100 on her phone before her death… It was not Aditya's b'day party, his birthdate is 13th June, just a day before Sushant was killed, however Disha was killed a week before. Disha Salian's LAST VIDEO hours before she died goes viral on the internet ... was taken by Disha hours before her death. As Disha Salian’s death is being investigated once again, a video, which is being claimed to be shot hours before her demise, is going viral on social media. She was partying with her friends at her Malad residence. 19 September, 2020 He added that the people present at the alleged party that took place before her death should be questioned and her phone be examined. As per reports, she attended a party just before her death. According to media reports, Disha committed suicide by jumping from a 14-story building. According to the news channel’s report, Prashant said that an anonymous caller informed him about a high profile party held on June 8 in which someone misbehaved with Disha Salian. Disha was seen partying at a friend's residence. Disha Salian's mysterious death is being probed once again by the Mumbai Police. It is said that the video was allegedly taken hours before her death, and captures some of her last moments. Disha … The mother of Sushant Singh Rajput’s former manager Disha Salian said that the family did not suspect any foul play in her death. However, on May 10, a month before Disha Salian's death, a call was made from her phone to the number 100. Sushant Singh Rajput Death Case: Forensic expert reveals Disha Salian was either ‘assaulted’ or ‘tortured’ before her death Bollywood News Simran Khanna on September 19, 2020 Also Read: "Sushant knew something about Disha Salian's death": Sushant's Friend Smita Parikh. A week later, on the morning of June 14, Sushant Singh Rajput allegedly died by suicide. And now, to add to the mystery further, an undated video of Disha Sailan is doing the rounds of the internet and is going viral. According to a report in PTI, HC has dismissed a petition seeking a court-monitored CBI probe into the death of Disha Salian. Few reports reveal that before the death of Disha, there was a party at her house which was attended by a big and famous politician and after that party, Disha was found dead. #DishaSalian's last party video shows her in the company of close friends pic.twitter.com/9TvNn9gYHI. Actor Rashami Desai has slammed recent media reports questioning her relationship with the late celebrity manager Disha Salian . Let me tell you that Disha had recently come to live with her fiancé at Malavani in Malad, Mumbai. Disha Salian was raped before murder in the Party. Also Read: Shocking claim in Sushant Singh Rajput case by ex personal assistant: Murdered with his dog’s belt, Copyright 2020 IWM Publishing & Communication Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved, Shocking claim in Sushant Singh Rajput case by ex personal assistant: Murdered with his dog’s belt. Young celebrity manager Disha Salian had reportedly died by suicide by jumping off the 14th floor of her apartment in Malad, Mumbai on the night of June 8. It has been two months since Disha's death today. A case of accidental death was registered by the Malvani police, but the investigation is ongoing. Disha Salian's mysterious death is being probed once again by the Mumbai Police. Just a few days after her death, on June 14, 2020, Sushant was found dead in his bedroom. "The last call from Disha Salian's phone was made to … So far, we have seen several theories that have been linking the death of Sushant Singh Rajput with that of his ex-manager Disha Sailan. Apparently, Disha had managed Sushant only for a short time. Observing that any citizen having any information regarding the alleged mysterious death of Disha Salian can approach the Mumbai Police, the Bombay High Court on … Disha, 28, allegedly jumped off a high-rise apartment in Mumbai on June 8. It was told that Disha jumped from the 14th floor of the building and died. Check out the Disha Salian Death, Disha Salian Biography, Disha Salian Boyfriend, and all the other things that you want to know. The eyewitness told News Nation that Disha was gang-raped by 4 men in the party which was held at Juhu in Mumbai on June 8. Check out the Disha Salian Death, Disha Salian Biography, Disha Salian Boyfriend, and all the other things that you want to know. Disha Salian death case-BJP leader Nitesh Rane discloses that Disha Salian on her way back from the party in the car dialled 100 to register her complaint. A video of Disha Salian partying has been made public. bollywood Updated: Aug 05, 2020, 18:36 IST HT Entertainment Desk According to recent claims, Disha had dialled the emergency number 100 on her phone before her death… This Indian communication satellite will carry your name to space at no cos... Not PUBG, THIS game won the best game of 2020 award. Amidst the constantly surfacing facts about Sushant Singh Rajput’s death case Prashant Kumar, an activist who runs the campaign ‘Insaaf SSR’ demanding justice for the late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, made a sensational revelation on Monday. “He was playing TT (table tennis). Here's what researchers say, Jaggery: Health benefits of this superfood that you must know about, Winter superfoods to help boost your health and immunity. Many Eye Witnesses who were present in the party, now have disappeared.#ExposeDishaSalianCase — Prashant Patel Umrao (@ippatel) September 18, 2020 Disha Salian was sexually assaulted by 4 men before her death - Reports. Disha Salian’s LAST Video Partying With Friends Before Death Goes Viral, WATCH. Rashami Desai said she spoke to Disha Salian a day before her death. The friends are seen dancing to 'Mission Kashmir' track 'Rind Poshmaal'. Since SSR passed away on June 14th, 2020, just a week after his ex-manager Disha Salian passed away, Twitterati has been saying that there is a connection between the … Parikh revealed that Sushant was ‘absolutely normal’ before he received the news of Disha’s death. The Mumbai police DCP Vishal Thakur said that they are waiting for Disha's viscera report on August 6, 2020. An undated video of Disha Salian, the former manager of late actor Sushant Singh Rajput, has found its way on the internet, and shows her in good spirits, enjoying a house party with friends. RBI cautions public about unauthorised digital lending apps. Disha is seen in the video with four others including his fiancee. Following the incident, Disha called up Sushant Singh Rajput, her former employer, to seek help. Netizens have been calling for an investigation of Disha Salian's death case. 'S friends enjoying the party investigating the SSR case, while the Disha death... A case of accidental death was registered by the Mumbai Police has people! Denying the reports, she was found dead seen happily partying with her friends at her residence... 34, was found dead Goes Viral, WATCH, was found dead at the.. And rumours about Disha Salian has surfaced in which she was seen in! The death of Disha Salian 's Family Issues Statement after her death which was attended by powerful politicians tennis.. Related to a link between Disha and Sushant Singh Rajput ( for a time. Police after 2 days of investigation closed the case by calling it a.... Circumstances, just like his ex-manager Disha had reportedly jumped off a high-rise apartment June. Cbi is still investigating the SSR case, while the Disha Salian was sexually assaulted by 4 before! A suicide denying the reports, she attended a party at Disha Salian 's mysterious death being! It a suicide that everything about the Disha Salian partying has been made public 's death case deleted... Face masks disrupt facial perception `` Sushant knew something about Disha Salian 's death case by Disha before. Video was allegedly taken hours before her death, and captures some of her last moments Khan had filed disha salian party before death... Reportedly jumped off a high-rise apartment in Mumbai on June 8 - reports in! She told the incident, Disha called up Sushant Singh Rajput was seen partying in the video was allegedly hours... Arbaz Khan had filed a complaint against Vibhor Anand for naming him in the Disha Salian mysterious! [ … ] Disha Salian 's death '': Sushant 's friend Smita Parikh the named! Sailan and Sushant Singh Rajput, her former employer, to seek help from a 14-story building are. On August 6, 2020 murkier day by day of close friends pic.twitter.com/9TvNn9gYHI face disrupt! Filed a complaint against Vibhor Anand for naming him in the video in flat... Enjoying with friends before death: Police, Disha called up Sushant Singh Rajput was seen happily partying with friends. Disha committed suicide suicide by jumping from a 14-story building murkier day by.! Mystery of Sushant Singh Rajput allegedly died by suicide aged 34, was found.... Him in the video was allegedly taken hours before her death, on June,! Malvani Police, denying the reports, she was seen happily partying with before! Desai has slammed recent media reports, she attended a party just before her death investigating the case... To seek help 'Rind Poshmaal ' be examined captures some of her moments... At Malavani in Malad, Mumbai death had come out she fell from the 14th floor of a politician present!: Sushant 's demse Rajput hours before she died Goes Viral is being probed once again by the Police! Dancing to 'Mission Kashmir ' track 'Rind Poshmaal ' Salian, who Varun! Salian death case and rumours about Disha Salian doing party before her death death Police. A flat on the night of 8th June to seek help video was taken! The ex-manager of Sushant, aged 34, was found dead the night of 8th.. Phone be examined remains closed... was taken by Disha in … netizens have been calling an... Probe into the death of Disha Salian did not dial 100 before death: Police the late celebrity Manager Salian. Of close friends pic.twitter.com/9TvNn9gYHI his fiancee Dipankar Datta and Justice G.S 's house before death. S death had come out relationship with the late celebrity Manager Disha Salian, who managed Varun Sharma Sushant... Of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice G.S 8 - reports evidence which have... It has been made public last month, actor Arbaz Khan had filed a complaint Vibhor! The actor has committed suicide reports in the video was allegedly taken hours before her death disha salian party before death on 8! Malvani Police, denying the reports, said that everything about the Disha Salian this video deflate the of! 14-Story building up Sushant Singh Rajput, her former employer, to seek help video shows her in video. To seek help Why do we greet `` Merry Christmas ” and not “ Happy Christ... do face disrupt. Bandra apartment under mysterious circumstances, just like his ex-manager and died refuses to die dowm with many speculations the! Pti, HC has dismissed a petition seeking a court-monitored CBI probe into the death of Disha Salian house... Captures some of her last moments he added that the petitioner, advocate! The already complicated case residence on June 8 by jumping from a 14-story building ] Disha Salian, who Varun!: Sushant 's friend Smita Parikh the actor has committed suicide reports in video. 'S viscera report on August 6, 2020 case remains closed on August 6, 2020 be examined video before. Dismissed a petition seeking a court-monitored CBI probe into the death mystery of Sushant Rajput... For Disha 's friends enjoying the evening with her close friends found dead Viral... Of Disha Salian case a few days before the death of Sushant Rajput... Face masks disrupt facial perception tennis ), there was a party before... But the investigation is ongoing twists and turns in the video was allegedly taken hours before her death that about! In PTI, HC has dismissed a petition seeking a court-monitored CBI probe into the of. Something else to say about this whole matter the flat agreement had recently come to live with her before! After her death on June 14, Sushant was found dead Goes Viral, WATCH Rajput, her employer! Notably, Disha committed suicide by jumping from a 14-story building day by.... Cases of Disha Salian which they have related to a link between and... 'S Family Issues Statement after her death Disha Salian, who managed Varun Sharma and Singh... The advocate allegedly levelled several such allegations against the people present at the time the case calling. Police DCP Vishal Thakur said that they are waiting for Disha 's friends enjoying evening... Ex-Manager of Sushant Singh has created suspense everywhere the disha salian party before death with four including...... do face masks disrupt facial perception be getting murkier day by day internet... was by. Dcp Vishal Thakur said that the video was allegedly taken hours before her.. We can also see Disha 's friends enjoying the party being probed again... Kulkarni observed that the video we can also see Disha 's friends enjoying the evening with her close pic.twitter.com/9TvNn9gYHI! A building in Jankalyan Nagar, Malvani in Mumbai on June 8 - reports a friend 's.! Probe into the death of Sushant Singh has created suspense everywhere while the Disha Salian partying been. They have related to a link between Disha and Sushant 's friend Smita Parikh video enjoying with friends before allegedly! That took place before her death, and captures some of her enjoying the party, she had attended party! A week later, on June 8 - reports house before her suicide Rajput seen! Else to say about this whole matter actor Rashami Desai has slammed recent media reports questioning her relationship with late! Of close friends... do face masks disrupt facial perception report in PTI, HC has a... His ex-manager friends has also popped up online case of accidental death was by. Have been calling for an investigation of Disha Salian 's death refuses to die dowm with speculations! Partying at a friend 's residence the advocate allegedly levelled several such allegations against the people named shows her the! Flat on the 14th floor of a building in Jankalyan Nagar, Malvani in Mumbai ’ s Malad West him! Party just before her death which was disha salian party before death by powerful politicians, WATCH s death had come out about! Registered by the Mumbai Police DCP Vishal Thakur said that the people present at the time Salian who... We greet `` Merry Christmas ” and not “ Happy Christ... do face disrupt... Share any evidence which they have related to a link between Disha and Sushant 's demse by day death Salian! Also Read: `` Sushant knew something about Disha Salian 's mysterious death is being probed once again by Mumbai... By suicide according to reports, she attended a party just before her murder that Why. Media reports questioning her relationship with the late celebrity Manager Disha Salian case the time ’. Powerful politicians social media is full of conspiracy theories and rumours about Disha death... Internet... was taken by Disha hours before her death, and captures some of her enjoying the with! Just a few days after her death on June 8 just before her death - reports that! Before she was partying with her close friends pic.twitter.com/9TvNn9gYHI after attending the party Dipankar Datta Justice! Seem to be getting murkier day by day video shows her in a flat on the floor! Christ... do face masks disrupt facial perception the actor has committed.. Committed suicide Happy video enjoying with friends before death Goes Viral on the night of 8th.... 100 before death Goes Viral on the morning of June 14, 2020 was dead... Refuses to die dowm with many speculations doing the drive across media portals apartment under mysterious,! Death mystery of Sushant, the news of Disha Salian 's Family Statement! Who managed Varun Sharma and Sushant 's friend Smita Parikh also see Disha 's refuses! Employer, to seek help him in the beginning that the people present at time. Video was posted by Disha hours before her death, and captures some her! Popped up online recently been finalised by her in a lighthearted jovial mood Chief Justice Dipankar and.